Thoughts on Herbie Kane!



  • I do hold but am just looking to have people's opinion.
    Liverpool player on loan at Doncaster Rovers last season and impressed.
    I can see him going out to Hull this season as that's where the Donny manager has gone.
    Does anyone know if he's the 'real deal' or not?
    Thanks.



  • Lacks pace and tends to go bananas.



  • He's my biggest hold (dont laugh).... i just think he's had nothing but positive things said about him... young/english and hes so cheap there really isnt much downside...he's that cheap that if he goes, hes gonna go



  • Might get a few MB next season if the papers mention H Kane!



  • @G27
    just to confirm, biggest hold interms of number of shares, not value



  • Any news on him going out on loan yet? I think the deadline is 15th? So hoping a few loan deals to go through next week



  • I got out! No Liverpool pre-season games, no transfer talk and vague loan deals mentioned.
    At one point Rangers were mentioned, but I think he might end up at Hull. (Ex Donny manager who he played under last season).
    Going to keep an eye on though!



  • @G27 see above πŸ˜€



  • @Dronny-Gaz said in Thoughts on Herbie Kane!:

    n

    just seems odd, rave reviews from everyone and seems like liverpool rate him but absolutley nothing. i thought there was an outside chance he'd be involved in england youth set up this summer after having a good season - but again nothing



  • @G27 I still think the potential is there. I just felt at the time I'd make money easier from other players than having it tied up in a player who's a bit stagnant at the moment.
    A good season in the Championship should raise his profile.
    Maybe a season with Gerrard at Rangers. He wasn't a bad midfielder πŸ˜€



  • rangers would be a good move - him and Aribo centre mid... they look much improved this year



  • Sounds like he is staying at Liverpool and will get game time in the cups.

    You still hold loads @G27 ?

    If he does start to come on the scene, I think he will head towards Β£1 quite quickly.



  • Just to compare to other English yths in top teams that won't/don't play...

    Conor Gallagher at Chelsea is Β£1.19
    James Garner at Utd (think hes made 1 app) Β£1.50



  • Yeah, looks like there's lots of potential for capital appreciation with Herbie, when he gets game time for Liverpool in the League Cup.



  • I'll get back on if he picks squad number 53.

    Like the carπŸš—πŸš—πŸš—πŸš—πŸš—πŸš—



  • He won't get in the team for the league cup (bench maybe but even that I'd doubt) he's miles away from the team and has Lallana, Keita, Milner, Ox-Chambo, and even Curtis Jones ahead of him at the moment who aren't starting games. That a lot of competition for three midfield places. Most likely place for him is U23s... Thats not to say people won't buy him and there isn't money to be made, just don't think he'll be starting in the League Cup cause he won't!



  • @9stevo

    Maybe you’re right, but if that’s the case why did Liverpool block his loan move to Rangers?



  • @ocs123 no idea could be any number of things. For a start Klopp is famously not keen on loans, they're much more an exception than the norm at liverpool. He likes having his players (youth and first team) at melwood, in fact the first thing he did when he took over from Brendan was cancelled all loans. Not looking to argue with anyone just wanted to let people know he's nowhere near the team and is unlikely to play in the cups.



  • @Westy

    haha this is the first player i'm truley gutted about - i banged the drum for ages and then sold him last week...saw the news last night after a few beers!....i needed a few more to get over it



  • @G27 he has now stalled.

    When does the loan window close? Maybe some waiting for that.

    As soon as he's on the bench in any game he goes up 10-20p more quickly I reckon.


Log in to reply
 

Looks like your connection to Football Index Forum was lost, please wait while we try to reconnect.