• @ChazFI123 Perhaps - but its all the data i've got to go on. Is Dybala likely to "block" PB for Mbappe to the same level that Neymar currently does though? I would say that's doubtful.

  • @MrWh1te I'm not sure Icardi's MB potential at PSG is greater than Mbappe's. That's a judgement call, but Mbappe has the Euros coming up so all eyes will be on him. I would say his MB prospects will improve over the next 12 months and keep getting better.

    Again, its a judgement call. I feel more confident making these sorts of judgements/predictions about Mbappe though, than i would about backing the likes of Greenwood to reach the heights some are predicting with such certainty.

  • @ScoutScout

    I think both Pep and Klopp are both fighting really hard behind the scenes.
    So hard I suggest, that is has even scared off the big two in Spain.
    That's what the most recent talk I've heard is hinting at, for me it goes a long way to explaining the relative "spike" of £2

  • I totally don't understand why people compare Icardi with Mbappe.

    Icardi had his best season (2017-2018) and did not even make the bench for Argentina. At the same time, Mbappe was a world cup star and champion at the age of 20.

    Currently, Mbappe is the most valuable player in the world and Icardi is a disaster. Inter want to get rid of him (even Lautaro Martinez is better than him now). It is so ridiculous to compare Icardi to Mbappe.

  • @MrWh1te Why can Icardi get a MB? He has never won any MB and what makes him become Media friendly when moving to FRANCE?

  • @Victory

    If his Mrs moves to England he'll become the MB king :p

  • I have a horrible feeling City will buy him😬

  • @Wotabeast
    I like your last sentence "...he is an excellent pick on FI for those with a long term strategy"!!
    That why he isnt in my port and others like Pogba, Neymar...I'm playing game on front of me and I expect 'money' now , not in nxt year, two years later or when Messi/Ronaldo will go to retire!! Like @Stevo said and I agreed with him, I prefer 10 shares of 1 player sub £1 or 7 players £1 sub then him cuz I'm sure they will delivery more (cap app/IPD) then him so I dont see the point to hold him for so long when you can make money elsewhere!But looks like he ticked all boxes for you...

  • @C-Arroyo Have not seen you for a while. Where have you been over the Summer?

  • @Victory

    Hiding out on the West Wales coast, in a rain splattered teepee with a gas bottled stove, water from a spring and not a phone charging socket for miles.

    It isn't that my shares don't appreciate, or that I'm against consumption.
    I just choose to reinvest in more shares, to pay for my decadent retirement :)

  • @C-Arroyo That sounds fun.

    I 'd like to leave my port for couple months without touching it, but the fact is I am currently checking my portfolio and forum 100 times/a day no matter what I am in the office, weekend or on vacation.

  • Quick question guys? Do I sell up my Mbappe’s and top up on Hazard? I think Hazard has hit his bottom, he should be back in a week or two and should win more dividends than Mbappe. Thoughts?

  • @Failtips said in Mbappe:

    Quick question guys? Do I sell up my Mbappe’s and top up on Hazard? I think Hazard has hit his bottom, he should be back in a week or two and should win more dividends than Mbappe. Thoughts?

    No, keep Mbappe. You'll thank me for it in the long-run.

  • @Boris999 cheers pal

  • @Failtips you can put some money into Hazard that might well be a good move.
    But don't sell Mbappe for it.
    He's young, very.
    He's going to star for France in the Euros, they could win it.
    He will move from PSG in time (I reckon next summer), probably to Real.

    Imagine the potential for a rise in price and MB if you stay patient. That's my advice anyway, I topped a little. Let's hope it was worth it! Good luck mate.

  • I recently sold Mbappe but I absolutely intend to get back on later in the season as the euros approach.
    The reason I sold was prompted by the injury but I was already considering it due to his seemingly CURRENT inability to win divs of any kind (pb or mb).
    I was stubborn for a long while and ignored other traders comments of "your £7 per share in Mbappe can earn you much more much faster invested elsewhere"....until he pulled up the other night and that's when I gave in.

    Havingc said this, I'd advise you to HOLD Mbappe. I'm sure he'll come good eventually.

    I just needed capital to fund my shortterm flipping strategy and Mbappe just happened to be the weakest link at the time I decided to embark on this new direction.

  • Why rely on possible future MB & PB winnings (which may or may not happen), when you can buy Neymar now for circa £7? He's won 81p in dividends (11% yield) in the last 100 days alone, without playing in a single match.

    His transfer to Barcelona looks highly unlikely to happen before the window closes (Barcelona are £60m-£70m short of PSG's asking price and Dembele is refusing to move the other way as a make-weight), which means he will probably stay at PSG and begin returning massive PB scores again after the international break (his PB baseline is the highest of any player on the Index).

    Then next Summer the whole Barca / Real media circus will kick off all over again!

  • @ocs123 Cause people are expecting Mbappé to have another monster season at PSG, followed by being France's poster boy for the Euros, followed by a summer transfer saga to Madrid (whether he goes or not is irrelevant, when MB winnings are expected to be a regular)
    Like @Sill7 mentioned on this thread before, if you're buying Mbappé, you're not really buying for the short term are you, you're buying for future dividends and getting in cheap before his price rockets when he is (hopefully) expected to win dividends later in his career.

  • Hold neymar and mbappe. Mbappe has earned me £2.50 in 3 months. Sold 150 shares in him to free up funds still hold 100 shares. Neymar has earned me £50 in just over 2 weeks more dividends to come tonight and I hold 200 shares. Basically neymar in just over 2 weeks has earned me more dividends than messi Salah hazard who I’ve held for a few months.

  • With Neymar looking nailed on to Barca now, and money being moved out of him (he's dropped 6p in the past 30 mins or so), will we see some big money going into Mbappe? Surely his PB will only benefit from Neymar's exclusion?

Log in to reply

Looks like your connection to Football Index Forum was lost, please wait while we try to reconnect.