Tammy Abraham or Lukaku?



  • @RU99 Good time to top up if you ask me.



  • @NewUser152089

    Lukaku big drop!!! Time to top up!



  • Took a bit of a hammering, all these philosophies about getting either Alcacer or Lukaku.

    I got Abraham in the end, I rest my case looks like best option of the 3.



  • @NewUser152089

    Lukaku would be a good buy especially atm.. after a considerable drop.. . He will contonue with media dividends and he surely will continue scoring! Current price is great value imo



  • @Zola25 Said this last week too, reality is Tammy Abraham has gone up nicely whilst Lukaku has further dropped so the right decision was made.



  • @NewUser152089

    True .. tammy has seen considerable rise BUT rmmbr FI matrix doesnt suit him.. .he aint gettin a hat rick every game.. lukaku better value for money atm.. sensi better than both!



  • @Zola25 It doesn’t matter really what the PB matrix says - why aren’t people getting that. Fundamentally yes it matters to the FI product I get that. However, I’m sitting on a 190% capital appreciation gain on Abraham which is far better than hoping for dividends in other players that won’t ever match that gain.



  • @TeamGB
    It absolutely DOES matter because all the new guys that aren't fully understanding it atm will soon enough start to chase the divs more and the cap app will be less for those who don't fit.



  • @TeamGB

    Offcourse.. and good on you with abraham.. never rated him highly but fair play he bangin the goals in.. .



  • @MrWh1te Yes and then they’ll be new guys again after the current newbies become experienced. It goes on and on to a point which I’m currently enjoying by making a lot of capital appreciation on a large number of players.

    Also, Abraham is also winning MB today and has also won some more MB dividends recently so it’s not all about current PB. If this guy continues to be the real deal and decides to play for England then he’s a decent hold.



  • @TeamGB I hold him and am banking on it :)



  • @TeamGB you might be sitting on a good chunk of cap app just now but if and when people get bored of him not winning divs or cap app is more profitable elsewhere his price could tumble. Problem with cap app players is the price only has to drop a little bit and a mass sell off could begin as everyone worries the inevitable drop has started.

    You need a dividend return to sustain a price so when chasing cap app the key is getting out at the right time unfortunately no one can know for sure where the peak is so set your own target to sell at



  • @Black-wolf He won MB last night. He will win a lot more MB if he decides to play for England, the Euros is coming, etc. I won’t be selling.



  • @TeamGB he definitely will if he picks england and then becomes first choice striker. That means replacing kane though and from all the hype im hearing of Greenwood he’s destined to be England’s next top striker 🙄. I like Abraham i just think hes route to the top is blocked by too much talent ahead of him. If he does puck england over nigeria he’s still got a lot of work to do to get into the first team


Log in to reply
 

Looks like your connection to Football Index Forum was lost, please wait while we try to reconnect.