Foden- Grealish- Maddison ? Which one 🤣



  • Who would you choose from an index perspective and give your reasons please. I can’t decide



  • @AML-Trading said in Foden- Grealish- Maddison ? Which one 🤣:

    Who would you choose from an index perspective and give your reasons please. I can’t decide

    Grealish. I can't see him staying at Villa, and he's a character, so will get some MB. Maddison is also a character (remember him getting caught at a casino when he was supposed to be injured and missed the England squad?) But I can't see him leaving Leicester. Hold Grealish and Maddison.



  • Glad you said these points as that’s part of my thoughts. Foden has quality but seems a nice boy. The other 2 especially Grealish there seems some added spice in there. Wonder where he ends up



  • Grealish for me. I do hold at a good profit but I reckon when he finally does get that call up there's going to be 🚀🚀🚀



  • Or what about possibly going 50 of each?



  • Maddison, think he'll be the best PB returner of the trio. Can't see where the Foden divs will come from when city players struggle for media and he'll be up against kdb/Rodri for PB when he's not on the bench, don't think Grealish gets the factored in to his price United move.



  • @NallyCat true, Grealish maybe over the last 4 months has a united move in his price but then I thought that of Bruno lol. It’s so hard, Maddison hasn’t risen yet he’s down 40p from where he was



  • As things stand, Grealish is the best player, the most likely to move, and the most likely to get MB. So him.



  • This post is deleted!


  • @Carboney foden doesnf have the same mb as the other two though. That's what would make me learn more towards the other two



  • @AML-Trading Believe it or not Foden is probably from the worst background of all 3. City have done an amazing job shielding him and bringing him up as I’m lead to believe his family network was not stable to say the least



  • I do hold all 3, but I'll throw in a curve ball and suggest David Brooks and Dwight McNeil.
    Equally talented and both could be on their way this Summer.
    The 3 mentioned act as a marker for where their price will easily go.
    All good holds.
    If Grealish ends up at United he'll be a £10 player. He's one of those characters and has the talent.

    With David Silva and Leroy Sane potentially leaving, Foden should get his chance to shine.

    Maddison seems quite settled at Leicester at the moment. Money talks though obviously.

    All 3 could be lining up in the England side for the Euros.

    There seems to be a lot of young talented midfielders about at the moment.



  • Foden will be a future PB master IF he gets full games under Pep.

    Madison and Grealish don’t hold any value at their current price.

    In the same ball park however is Mount, at almost half the price of these 3 I see far more value there.



  • I only have Foden but imo I would rank them as follows-

    1. Grealish, will move and attracts a lot of Media attention. Quality player who should flourish with better players around him.

    2. Foden. Should hopefully make his breakthrough if next season ever gets underway. If he doesn't make his breakthrough I fully expect him to look for a move away and there will be no shortage of takers. Also the potential to be a Media darling as the next big English hope.

    3. Maddison- the boy is quality but I don't see him leaving Leicester any time soon. Very capable PB wise bit think the other 2 have a slight edge over him.

    In all honesty though, all 3 are good holds.



  • @Dronny-Gaz said in Foden- Grealish- Maddison ? Which one 🤣:

    I do hold all 3, but I'll throw in a curve ball and suggest David Brooks and Dwight McNeil.
    Equally talented and both could be on their way this Summer.
    The 3 mentioned act as a marker for where their price will easily go.
    All good holds.
    If Grealish ends up at United he'll be a £10 player. He's one of those characters and has the talent.

    With David Silva and Leroy Sane potentially leaving, Foden should get his chance to shine.

    Maddison seems quite settled at Leicester at the moment. Money talks though obviously.

    All 3 could be lining up in the England side for the Euros.

    There seems to be a lot of young talented midfielders about at the moment.

    Grealish a £10 player at United? Bruno isnt even at £10 and is a gun, both MB/PB and on the pitch. United dont need Grealish, they're fine wide left with Martial/Rashford. They need a right winger to replace the road runner, and a striker. I cant see them spending big on 3 players. And if Pogba stays, no chance United buy Grealish as Pogba always likes to go into that left channel and they'd get in each others way - problems United have had before in getting the best out of Pogba!

    So I think his price is a bit steep atm - look at Maddison, he was £5 when playing well before xmas and linked to United, now he's settled much lower.

    Foden has the world at his feet imo, is Englands future star and can go and play wherever he wants!


Log in to reply