With PB in Mind (Poll)
-
With the div increase just round the corner, these are the top 10 current PB monsters (avg score since 19 Aug 2017) if you could buy only one - who would it be?
-
Savanier for me. I've bought him via the ME over the weekend and he was 1 of my picks for the next phase of the Ferret league so I've backed him.
I'm not suggesting he'll win more PB divs than the others in this poll but it's about value for me. At £1.50ish, he's a no-brainer with his record.
-
This post is deleted!
-
Kimmich for me...dominant player in a dominant team. Champions League gold days...no brained at current price
-
@Stevo These are the top 10 players from the date mentioned for avg PB scores in any game that they could earn divs from.
Once this poll closes, i will run another one which is from maybe 19 Aug 2018 to see what names change and then again for 2019 and then maybe just this year - see what trends there are etc....
-
@Vaughany exactly what I would have said.
-
Bruno, he plays villa on the day of the announcement, europa fixtures incoming also.
-
@Tom77 I think the new divs will apply for the next day personally
-
@Millerman OK thanks yeah sounds good. Was just a bit surprised to see some of them in the top 10.
-
@NewUser218616 said in With PB in Mind (Poll):
@Tom77 I think the new divs will apply for the next day personally
‘’ This will be published on Thursday 9th July 2020 and will be in force from publication date through to the end of next season’’
-
The only one in Kimmichs age bracket is Bruno and hes about £6.50 dearer or about 245% of kimmich's price
The only one really close to Kimmich's price is KDB who is 4 years older and in a less dominant team who may be banned from European competition
Arguably the only one with Kimmich's consistency is Messi who's 33 years old and 50p dearer. Arguably Neymar is very consistent but seldom actually plays and is approaching 200% of Kimmich's price but even at that I'd say he was the next best buy on the list. Arguably Kroos is nearly as consistent but is 30. Arguably Parejo is as consistent but he fought in 2 wars and Valencia are by no means assured of European competition next season.
That's why I think Kimmich is the biggest no brainer around at present
-
So what you seem to be saying is, Joshua Kimmich is the most underpriced player on the index right now?
You could be right mate!
-
@ScouseSte arguably 😉
-
He'll hit £5 on Thursday mate.
These non-pb youth rises are making the dividend earners look very cheap!
-
How many times has kimmich won pb as a midfielder?
-
@Tom77 said in With PB in Mind (Poll):
How many times has kimmich won pb as a midfielder?
Once, same amount of times Bruno has won PB at United
-
@Tom77 same amount of times as 46p Gaston Ramirez but like I often say, cap app is driven by likelihood of divs and very few are likely to be in the mix as many times as Kimmich, and none at under 30 y/o and under a tenner
-
@Tom77 Can't remember when he changed but not sure the return of football since COVID is a fair reflection of PB given the impact of the number substitutions especially.
-
@ChazFI123 said in With PB in Mind (Poll):
@Tom77 said in With PB in Mind (Poll):
How many times has kimmich won pb as a midfielder?
Once, same amount of times Bruno has won PB at United
Because that doesn't reflect his historic pb wins does it, he would be 8 or 9 quid if he was a defender.
Why bring bruno in to it
-
@Tom77 my point is Kimmich has started 8 games listed as a midfielder and he's won PB once. I could say 'how many times has Bruno won PB at united?' to try and argue he's not a premium PB hold for example, but there's many other factors to consider rather than just how many times they've won
