Pogba, Hold or sell

  • This isn't the words of a player that doesn't care @johnboywalker, I know that wasn't your exact words, but kinda what you meant.

    Now he needs to show us on the pitch on Wednesday, not expecting a win but a performance would be enough for most of us that support Manchester United

    0_1555951155498_Screenshot_20190422-183338_Chrome Beta.jpg

  • @Andy-M

    So he is criticising himself, his own performance and that of his teammates. What a big man. He was the worst of the lot on Sunday.

    He is now a 26 year old man, yet still behaves like a petulant 18 year old.

    How do you think Sir Alex would have dealt with Pogba? I'm almost certain he would join the long list of superstars that Fergie dumped as they thought they were bigger than the club itself.

    I'm now hearing that he apparently didn't go over to the away fans after the game on Sunday.

    That pretty much sums him up completely.

    I just read the full interview and admittedly he talks a good game. Let's see on Wednesday if his actions back up his words.

  • @Andy-M said in Pogba, Hold or sell:

    @Dan-The-Man What are you trying to say with that more relevant graph ????

    That even with an artificial bump from the media bonus, he's dropping, which shows how risky he is.

    I think we parted ways on this debate, the second you revealed that you look at portfolio rises in pennies rather than percentages.

    I'm not saying Pogba will freefall from where he is but it's not reasonable to suggest £2 growth from Pogba is superior to £1 growth from Pulisic. Enjoy your night dude, I'm sure we'll get in to this another time ha....


    I've made a case for why I don't hold Pogba but for the record... I'm not saying he's going to freefall from this day forward until the end of time. The index as a whole will continue to grow significantly as the months go by and I expect Pogba to grow too, albeit with some dips along the way. I just believe the Pogba Bubble is big... risky and will produce lower returns than other players. So a lot of risk... for less rewards.

    Worth noting though.... that almost everyone who joined has a story about how bad they were wrong lol.

  • @johnboywalker Worst of the lot 🤔 watched the game and disagree mate, obviously these ratings say different to you too ...

    Only Lindelöf and Ole went to the away fans, you are really pinpointing Pogba there 🤣🤣


  • Sorry for starting this thread but its been great reading everyones thoughts on the CURRENT FI media king.

    I am relatively new to this and asked the question as I feel he is too expensive for any significant capital appreciation.

    I accept all of your comments in respect of MB but as I only hold a few shares in Pogba, I am not willing to invest heavily in a player with restricted capital appreciation.

    I hold 60+ players and two thirds of them have increased in value more in percentage terms than when I purchased Pogba (at the SS) so for that reason and for my strategy Im OUT of the Pogba express train.

    Good luck to all of you who are invested and I suspect that is most on this thread judging by the comments but IMO my cash will be spent on cheaper players with less risk of heavy depreciation and potential for growth.

  • @Andy-M Andy, I was just looking into Media buzz a couple of years ago.

    I appreciate that Pogba is the undisputed Current media king but I think even you would agree that cant last forever and that was my point

  • @Dan-The-Man Very good points and Thanks for the nod with Pulisic

  • @Vespasian32 said in Pogba, Hold or sell:

    @Dan-The-Man I think pogba sweeps up a tonne of MB throughout summer whilst Pulisic hovers at his current price. Then Pulisic goes down when he can't even make the team sheet because Chelsea will replace Hazard with someone better than Pulisic...

    22 hours later...

    0_1556016908748_Screen Shot 2019-04-23 at 11.51.46.png


  • @Dan-The-Man

    Lucky but fair play hope you put your wallet where your mouth is and actually held a good number of Pulisic!? If Grujic carries on... I'll buy the first pina colada

  • @Vespasian32

    Bought a few when I first joined at the end of December and keep using dividends to buy more. This bit of growth has come earlier than I anticipated to be honest.

    0_1556017159209_Screen Shot 2019-04-23 at 11.58.57.png

    My plan is to have 300 by end of season and 600 before next season but with the 5 media spots increasing his chance of picking up dividends, his price has started increasing sooner than expected and now the CHO injury... I'm tempted to expedite things.

    I'm expecting big things over the next year out his futures, so it's all still early days as far as I can see.

  • Which one of you just sold 10,000 pogba? Come on own up

  • @Gregolocky2018 said in Pogba, Hold or sell:

    Which one of you just sold 10,000 pogba? Come on own up

    Wondered why my portfolio had dropped £200 and can see he has just dropped 20p. Sell queue or an actual deal?

  • @Zidave unfortunately wasn’t watching the ticker at the time

  • @Gregolocky2018 said in Pogba, Hold or sell:

    @Zidave unfortunately wasn’t watching the ticker at the time

    I am. A few 300 share sells but not a huge amount but his price is bouncing around. I am keeping an eye on it.

  • Interesting if this backfires on the clever cloggs responsible. The first 20p was all sell queue.

  • Plenty instant selling at 7.10 - madness

  • This is orchestrated sabotage. Dont fall for it boys and girls.

  • @Le-Blanc said in Pogba, Hold or sell:

    This is orchestrated sabotage. Dont fall for it boys and girls.

    Instant Sell has been suspended again.

  • This post is deleted!

Log in to reply

Looks like your connection to Football Index Forum was lost, please wait while we try to reconnect.