Pogba, Hold or sell



  • @Andy-M

    I think he is a good hold on FI for both PB and MB, although a little too expensive for me.

    In the real world, I think Pogba is at the root of the problems at Utd mate. He plays when it suits him. He has the potential to be the best midfielder in the world. On occasions, he shows it.

    But when he downs tools, he brings everyone else with him. I think he has seen an opportunity to move on (Madrid, Zidane), and his recent performances reflect this.

    Personally, I have far more respect for boys like Smalling and Jones, who know their limitations but give everything for the club. Are they good enough for Utd? Probably not. But the desire they show every week is admirable.

    There is no substitute for hard work.



  • @johnboywalker Totally agree on Jones and Mike Smalling 🤣🤣 miss Van Gaal sometimes.

    Even Ashley young, a lot of heart, but unfortunately none of the 3 are cut out for Manchester United.

    If Pogba wants to leave then fine with me, but I wouldn't get rid unless he requested, just my opinion though.



  • @Andy-M said in Pogba, Hold or sell:

    @Dan-The-Man 100% 300 x Pogba

    You must like dividends more than money mate. I don't get it.

    Just don't get why you think people want to get out,

    Well because I'm a person... and I got out. There's a ton of people who got in and are regretting it at the minute.

    When are you going to get out of Pogba?

    Ole has said in his interviews that he wants to build a team around Pogba and he'll be captain next season, facts over articles 😁

    Yeah... except that's not strictly a fact is it. He did say he wants to build around him.... several months ago... when everything was all rosey and Pogba was trying to impress. New broom sweeps clean comes to mind.

    If Pogba goes up £7.80 then that'd surely be 100% 🤣🤣 why are we comparing 20% with 100% ???

    No....

    You can buy roughly 5 Pulisic for 1 Pogba. You can't compare an £7.80 player against a £1.60 player on a 1 for 1 basis mate. Your option isn't buy one or the other... it's "How do you spend the £7.80"



  • This post is deleted!


  • When the big boys come in with 40k to deposit for the next bonus who do we think is gonna get a fat chunk of it....
    Proven mb and pb winners.
    Pogba sancho messi ronaldo kane sterling neymar



  • @Dan-The-Man doesn't matter if you can buy 5 Pulisic for 1 Pogba, I currently hold 500 Pogba and ( IF ) i was going to buy any Pulisic then it would probably also be 500, not 2500, so 1p rise is exactly the same for any player.
    There is absolutely no reason that Pulisic won't fall in price, his price went up due to the transfer speculation, once he arrives it can go either way mate, if he has a couple of great games then he'll fly, if he has a couple of bad games, or sits on bench then he will plummet.
    It's funny how you are obsessed with % in this discussion, how about we discuss Pogba falling 32p and Pulisic falling 32p would u like to tell me what that means ?? 😁



  • @Andy-M said in Pogba, Hold or sell:

    @Dan-The-Man doesn't matter if you can buy 5 Pulisic for 1 Pogba, I currently hold 500 Pogba and ( IF ) i was going to buy any Pulisic then it would probably also be 500, not 2500, so 1p rise is exactly the same for any player.

    Oh Andy...

    Andy, Andy, Andy...

    I have to stop you there mate.

    I thought we were having a serious discussion. Not some weird trolling thing.



  • would be quite nice if he got a pb win soon tho to silence the haters though and stem the selling.



  • This post is deleted!


  • @Andy-M said in Pogba, Hold or sell:

    doesn't matter if you can buy 5 Pulisic for 1 Pogba, I currently hold 500 Pogba and ( IF ) i was going to buy any Pulisic then it would probably also be 500, not 2500, so 1p rise is exactly the same for any player.

    Can't let you get away with that one mate ha

    • £3900 worth of Pogba is apparently the exact same as £805 worth of Pulisic

    You can't have meant that can you?

    • 1p rise is exactly the same for any player.

    Really?

    Surely that's a gag right?



  • I think what he means is no person is gonna hold 2500 pulisic. You just dont wanna have that much of one player. So even tho he is worth so much less he's not gonna be able to buy that much.

    He's not factoring the money left over he could spend on other players tbf tho so its not exactly fair.



  • @LuaLua

    It's worrying that he thinks a 1p rise... means the same thing for different players.



  • @Dan-The-Man it does. Regardless of the ROI cash earned is the same and thats what's important. I'll happily buy 1000 shares in the next bloke to go up 10p whether he costs £10 a share or 10p...what I earn is the same.



  • I would hold. I have 500 of him and he's currently at a 15p lost. The season is soon to close, and he'll be in the top 5 MB more times than not. I'm happy to collect the dividends.
    For traders with a low value port, I can see why he would be a risky hold because of his price.



  • @Vespasian32 But if its Pogba going up 10p V Terrier going up 10p you're going to make a shedload more off terrier at 89/99p than Pogba's 10p rise as you've got the extra 2% tax to pay out

    Or am I wrong



  • Pogba is bought for MB dividends. Dividends take patience- like a savings account. Summer media coming. Hold.



  • @Munchie63 true story.



  • @Munchie63

    Doh!

    If 2 players rise by 10p, their commission rises the same amount because it's a percentage.



  • I don't know if there's a WhatsApp group I'm out of the loop on or if there's a well executed, mass orchestrated troll... or if y'all are serious.... BUT no.... it's not the same.

    500 x 6p Rafael Marquez goes up 10p, you've nearly tripled your money. 500 x £7.80 Pogba goes up 10p, you've not even covered the spread to sell him, never mind tripled your money and you've had £3900 tied up instead of £30. Opportunity cost is a real thing people.



  • @Dan-The-Man Listen Danny boy 😁

    As it stands right now, there is Zero reason that Pulisic won't plummet, he has virtually no MB or BP, yes his price might rise 20% with a couple of goals, but capital appreciation is not exactly security in FI terms, if Pogba was looking like moving to Madrid then I'd dump without blinking, whereas Pulisic moving to a premier league team doesn't mean anything for me, it's already difficult trying to keep all the midfielders happy in Chelsea, he'll be sitting on the bench just as much as every other midfielder, that's when ppl decide to dump, remember 32p drop in price and 20% of his price is gone, Pogba can drop 32p and its only 4%, he'll easily make double that 32p in the summer media days.
    Anyway you clearly don't agree so let's wait and see, as soon as he's won Media a few days in a row then he's attractive again, this my friend is how the market works 😁


Log in to reply
 

Looks like your connection to Football Index Forum was lost, please wait while we try to reconnect.