@TraderJ pogba record from the spot isn't bad. But Rashford has been faultless and they are usually unsavable, and he's taken a few in really high pressure situations.

@TraderJ You would think considering the drop he had from not taking one. Fine margins indeed.

Rashford is simpley better at them though.

Let's open it up.

@Tom7471 wjat prices did you get in at? The timing is almost as important as who.

@Bradley117 why would money go into players in China and MLS? They have no value on the index. The only reason Rooney went up is because he's leaving the MLS

@TraderJ that's about a 15% rise over s year. By FI standards that's not a particually good investment. Particually if he has a drop in him I the near future.

@Tom7471 is there a January move on the cards for him? if not there probably isn't much value in holding him. You can always sell but keep an eye out for a future move.

@Cameron-Duffy Not bold, it's a bad trade. There is close to zero chance of him getting any divs or rises and could well be worthless by the end of the season. Unless he hits a monster score in a Europa League group game you'r better off cutting your losses.

Not true.

@Munchie63 I thought he was decent in the first half regardless of the penalty, and his PB half score reflected that. But we can agree to disagree on that. And I'll agree 5hathis contribution in the 2md half was clearly bigger.

You're not wrong on those states. But people seem to forget that rashford is 21. And he's spent most of the last 3 years under a manager that totally miss managed him. He was also clearly unfit towards the end of last season. He is the only player I had in red that I was happy to top up on and was bound to have alot of growth, wether it was today or later in the season.